19 Best Pizza Spots Across Major US Cities, According To Yelp
Craving a slice that rewrites your pizza expectations? Imagine molten cheese meeting blistered crusts while city skylines sparkle outside the window.
Yelp’s hungry hive has spoken, and the ovens are roaring coast to coast. Dive in, grab a napkin, and let each slice tell a delicious story you’ll want to taste twice.
1. Di Fara Pizza – New York, NY
If patience builds character, the wait here turns fans into philosophers. Hand-cut basil flutters over pies like confetti at a ticker-tape parade.
Sauce sings bright, mozzarella pulls long, and crust snaps with perfect char. Neighborhood legends whisper that one slice equals instant happiness, and the rumor feels wonderfully true.
2. Pizzeria Bianco – Phoenix, AZ
Desert air meets Old World spirit in a wood-fired love letter. Thoughtful toppings like housemade sausage and local vegetables ride a blistered crust with tender chew.
Bright tomato sauce balances creamy mozzarella. Sun-drenched dining spaces, friendly servers, and unforgettable seasonal specials turn a meal into a Southwestern pizza pilgrimage.
3. Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria – Chicago, IL
Deep-dish dreams come true in a buttery, golden pan. A river of cheese hides beneath chunky tomato sauce and crumbled sausage that snaps with spice.
Each slice stands tall like culinary architecture. Fans cheer for the caramelized crust edge, while visiting skeptics quickly convert after one gloriously hefty bite.
4. Tony’s Pizza Napoletana – San Francisco, CA
Multiple ovens, countless styles, and a champion pizzaiolo headline this culinary playground. Classic margherita arrives with leopard-kissed edges and bright balance.
Detroit squares crunch, New York rounds fold, and Sicilian slabs satisfy. Knowledgeable staff guide guests through styles with gusto, making every visit a tasting tour of pizza’s global dialects.
5. Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana – New Haven, CT
Coal-fired heat crafts legendary char and smoky perfume. White clam pie shines with briny sweetness, garlic, and crunchy crust that snaps like thin ice.
Lines form early, smiles linger late. Fan lore celebrates consistency, quick service, and that irresistible balance of chew and crisp which defines New Haven’s proud tradition.
6. Gino’s East – Chicago, IL
Graffiti-scribbled walls set the tone for a hearty feast. Rich, buttery crust cradles rivers of cheese and zesty sauce with chunky tomatoes.
Sausage patty pies earn loud applause. Tourists snap photos, locals nod knowingly, and the table goes quiet during that first molten, fork-and-knife dive into deep-dish bliss.
7. Modern Apizza – New Haven, CT
Slate ovens and old-school charm produce consistently excellent char. Tomato sauce leans savory, cheese melts into a creamy blanket, and toppings never overload the base.
Pepperoni curls into crisp little cups. Service moves briskly, the vibe stays friendly, and every bite echoes the city’s legendary apizza heritage with pride.
8. Pizzaiolo – Oakland, CA
Market-driven toppings and soulful dough share the spotlight in this artsy haven. Fresh herbs, delicate cheeses, and bright vegetables crown blistered crusts.
Spirited cocktails and lively playlists keep energy high. Date nights flourish by candlelight, while families celebrate a friendly neighborhood rhythm that turns dinner into an effortless ritual.
9. Antico Pizza Napoletana – Atlanta, GA
Communal tables and roaring ovens make meals feel like a party. Dough arrives soft, fragrant, and beautifully spotted, with San Marzano tomatoes lighting up each bite.
Garlic and basil perfume the air. Quick service, counter ordering, and no-nonsense style keep focus squarely on the fiery, flavorful heart of Naples.
10. Una Pizza Napoletana – New York, NY
Minimalist perfection sets the tone, where dough becomes the star. Slow fermentation delivers profound flavor and an ethereal interior crumb.
Toppings whisper, not shout, letting tomatoes and mozzarella glow. Candlelit serenity, attentive staff, and measured pacing transform dinner into a meditative celebration of Neapolitan craft and disciplined restraint.
11. Sally’s Apizza – New Haven, CT
Long lines hint at the smoky treasure inside. Thin crusts emerge charred yet pliant, carrying tangy sauce and pools of creamy cheese.
Pepperoni and onion thrill regulars, while white pies earn devoted fans. Family-run warmth, history-soaked walls, and a proud legacy create a timeless apizza experience worth the wait.
12. Lucali – Brooklyn, NY
Candlelit tables and hand-rolled dough bring romance to pizza night. Toppings stay classic, basil scattered generously, sauce bright and balanced.
BYOB fun pairs nicely with slow-paced service and anticipation. Locals whisper tips about arriving early, then savor that buttery, crisp-yet-tender crust like a secret you can happily share.
13. Apizza Scholls – Portland, OR
Attention to detail defines every bite, from long-fermented dough to restrained topping combos. The crust crackles, then yields to a gentle chew.
House sausage, pickled peppers, and careful bake precision win raves. Friendly staff guide guests through crowd favorites while the dining room hums with Portland’s relaxed, foodie-forward charm.
14. Pizzeria Mozza – Los Angeles, CA
Culinary star power meets joyous, crackly crusts. Creative toppings like squash blossoms, fennel sausage, and funky cheeses elevate every pie.
Appetizers and desserts deserve attention, making dinner feel like a well-paced show. Service remains sharp, wine list sings, and the lively room sparkles with Hollywood glow and neighborhood comfort.
15. Vito’s Pizza – Miami, FL
Sunny vibes and foldable slices bring beach-town energy indoors. Sauce leans slightly sweet, cheese stretches handsomely, and crisp edges deliver satisfying crunch.
Specialty pies add flair without fuss. Quick, friendly service keeps lines moving, while late-night hours rescue cravings after concerts, clubs, or spontaneous waterfront strolls along the bay.
16. Giovanni’s Pizza – Boston, MA
College crowds and lifelong locals unite over hearty, flavorful pies. Sauce carries classic Italian-American comfort, while toppings arrive generous without sinking the crust.
Garlic knots disappear quickly. Delivery runs brisk, dine-in feels cheerful, and that reliable cheese pull turns casual dinners into animated conversations about syrupy sunsets and second slices.
17. Prime Pizza – New York, NY
Slices shine under bright glass with classic swagger. Pepperoni cups crisp into tiny flavor chalices, and square pies deliver saucy comfort.
Dough holds integrity after a fold, passing the true slice test. Quick counter banter, clean space, and dependable quality create a go-to stop during busy city wanderings.
18. Pieology – Los Angeles, CA
Customization rules the stage, letting cravings drive the show. Guests build pies with speedy assembly and fiery ovens delivering crisp results.
Gluten-free and creative sauces broaden options. Wallet-friendly pricing, cheerful staff, and a fast-casual rhythm make it a convenient stop before movies, beach hangs, or late study sessions.
19. Blaze Pizza – Multiple Cities
Fast-fired magic turns handcrafted pies into quick, tasty meals. Dough bakes to a light crisp while toppings approach with playful variety.
Vegan cheese, spicy drizzles, and seasonal specials keep things interesting. Clean dining rooms, digital ordering, and efficient staff deliver dependable flavor without slowing down a bustling day.
