20 Most Haunted Hotels In Wisconsin That’ll Give You Chills
Wisconsin’s historic hotels hide more than just vintage charm – many harbor otherworldly residents who never checked out.
From luxurious Milwaukee landmarks to rustic country inns, these haunted hotspots offer spine-tingling encounters alongside comfortable accommodations.
Ready for a supernatural sleepover? Pack your courage and explore these twenty Wisconsin hotels where paranormal activity comes complimentary with your stay.
1. The Pfister Hotel – Milwaukee
Built in 1893, this grand Victorian masterpiece harbors the spirit of its original owner, Charles Pfister, who watches over guests from beyond the grave.
Major League Baseball players frequently request room changes after experiencing unexplained phenomena during team stays. Professional athletes report TVs turning on by themselves and personal belongings mysteriously relocating overnight.
2. The American Club Resort – Kohler
Once housing immigrant workers of the Kohler Company, this luxury resort now entertains more than just living guests.
Whispers of phantom footsteps echo through hallways after midnight, especially near the original dormitory sections. Staff members avoid certain areas alone, particularly the basement level where maintenance workers report tools mysteriously moving and unexplained cold spots forming.
3. Hotel Retlaw – Fond du Lac
Recently renovated to its 1920s grandeur, Hotel Retlaw’s restoration awakened dormant spirits lingering within its walls.
Guests capturing photos in the grand ballroom often discover mysterious orbs and unexplained figures in the background. Many report encounters with a ghostly woman in vintage attire wandering the mezzanine level, believed to be the wife of Walter Schroeder, the original owner.
4. Brumder Mansion Bed & Breakfast & Theater – Milwaukee
A haven for theatrical spirits, performers claim this Victorian mansion amplifies paranormal activity during productions.
Actors report costumes mysteriously rearranged backstage when nobody’s around. Guests staying in the Gold Suite frequently wake to invisible hands tucking them in, while the distinct scent of pipe tobacco wafts through rooms despite the no-smoking policy.
5. The Union Hotel – De Pere
Serving guests since 1883, this riverside inn counted notorious gangster Al Capone among its visitors.
Room 5 generates the most paranormal reports, with guests awakening to see a woman in white standing silently at the foot of their bed. Kitchen staff regularly find utensils rearranged overnight and occasionally hear childish giggles when nobody else is present.
6. Astor House Bed & Breakfast – Green Bay
Lovingly restored Victorian elegance masks a playfully mischievous spectral resident in this charming B&B.
Guests report jewelry and small objects vanishing only to reappear in unexpected places hours later. Morning conversations at breakfast often reveal multiple visitors experienced identical dreams about a young woman in period clothing showing them around hidden rooms not accessible in the current layout.
7. Old Rittenhouse Inn – Bayfield
Perched overlooking Lake Superior, this Queen Anne mansion hosts both paying guests and permanent spectral residents.
Visitors staying in the third-floor rooms report hearing furniture moving overhead despite being on the top floor. Staff regularly find dining room chairs rearranged in the morning, and the piano occasionally plays gentle melodies when nobody is near.
8. The Walker House – Mineral Point
Built by Cornish miners in 1836, this limestone inn preserves both Wisconsin’s mining history and its supernatural residents.
Guests sleeping in the third-floor rooms report being awakened by invisible miners discussing their day’s work in thick Cornish accents. Kitchen staff regularly find loaves of bread mysteriously sliced overnight, a callback to the building’s origins as a miners’ boarding house.
9. Best Western The Hotel Chequamegon – Ashland
Majestically overlooking Lake Superior, this hotel’s Victorian architecture conceals century-old secrets and restless spirits.
Guests frequently report televisions turning on spontaneously at 3 AM, always to static channels. Housekeeping staff avoid working alone on the fourth floor after multiple encounters with a ghostly bellhop who vanishes when approached.
10. The Boscobel Hotel – Boscobel
Standing since 1863, this historic hotel served as a makeshift hospital during a devastating flood, leaving lingering spirits of those who perished.
Maintenance workers report tools disappearing only to reappear in different locations. Overnight guests frequently awaken to sounds of rushing water and desperate cries for help, particularly during stormy nights.
11. Lake of the Torches Resort Casino – Lac du Flambeau
Built on ancient tribal grounds, guests report more than just gambling luck changing at this Northwoods resort.
Security cameras regularly capture unexplained light anomalies moving through the hotel corridors after midnight. Casino floor staff describe slot machines activating without players present, while housekeepers report finding perfectly arranged tribal symbols made from guest room items.
12. The Humbird Hotel Bar & Grill – Humbird
Surviving multiple fires since its 1870s construction, this small-town hotel harbors spirits seemingly bound to protect the historic structure.
Late-night bar patrons report seeing a man in period clothing checking pocket watches at empty tables. Kitchen staff regularly find burners mysteriously turned off when cooking temperatures rise too high, potentially preventing another devastating fire.
13. Menominee Casino Resort – Keshena
Modern amenities mask ancient spiritual connections at this tribal-owned resort where staff acknowledge regular paranormal encounters.
Guests report waking to find intricate dreamcatcher shadows projected on walls despite no physical source. Security personnel have documented unexplained temperature drops and equipment malfunctions during full moons, which tribal elders attribute to ancestral spirits visiting the grounds.
14. Four Seasons Resort – Pembine
Nestled along the Pemebonwon River, this northwoods getaway attracts fishermen, vacationers, and apparently, spirits unwilling to leave.
Guests staying in cabins report knocking sounds that follow specific patterns, seemingly trying to communicate. Fishing guides share stories of phantom canoes appearing on foggy mornings, paddled by Native American figures who vanish when approached.
15. Chenequa Country Club Mansion – Chenequa
Serving as an exclusive retreat for Milwaukee’s elite, this lakeside mansion harbors aristocratic spirits from Wisconsin’s gilded age.
Groundskeepers report garden tools rearranging themselves overnight and perfectly maintained sections appearing untouched for weeks. Evening events occasionally capture unexplained figures in formal attire from the early 1900s appearing in group photos, their faces always slightly blurred.
16. Big River Inn – Genoa
Overlooking the Mississippi River since 1879, this former boat-builders’ lodging houses spirits still watching the mighty waterway.
Guests routinely report lantern lights moving along the shoreline during foggy nights when no one is outside. Restaurant patrons occasionally find their drinks mysteriously sliding across tables, while staff report phantom cigar smoke wafting through the bar area despite smoking prohibitions.
17. The Karsten Nest – Kewaunee
Overlooking Lake Michigan, this quaint bed and breakfast conceals a century of secrets behind its charming facade.
Guests frequently report children’s laughter echoing through hallways late at night despite no children staying at the inn. Morning coffee service occasionally includes uninvited spectral guests, with visitors reporting seeing period-dressed figures sitting at empty tables who vanish when approached.
18. Franklin Street Inn Bed and Breakfast – Appleton
Victorian elegance masks paranormal mischief in this meticulously restored 1897 Queen Anne home.
Guests report antique music boxes playing spontaneously during the night, particularly in the Rose Room. Breakfast conversations often reveal multiple visitors dreamed of the same elderly woman showing them hidden passageways that don’t exist in the current floor plan.
19. Hotel Mead and Conference Center – Wisconsin Rapids
Modern business accommodations belie this hotel’s reputation for unexplained phenomena, particularly in its original wing.
Conference attendees report presentations disrupted by mysterious technical issues that technicians cannot explain. Overnight guests frequently mention being awakened by the sounds of old-fashioned typewriters clacking away in empty rooms, a ghostly echo of the building’s past as a paper company headquarters.
20. Old Baraboo Inn – Baraboo
Originally a rowdy railroad saloon and brothel from the 1860s, this establishment claims the title of Wisconsin’s most haunted pub.
Paranormal investigators flock here to capture EVPs of spectral voices answering direct questions. Bar patrons regularly report feeling invisible hands touching their shoulders, while staff members have documented glasses sliding across tables and bar stools spinning without human contact.
