10 Pizza Chains That Have Won Over Some Italian Expats

When Italians move abroad, finding pizza that tastes like home becomes a serious quest.

Most chains serve pies that don’t quite match what they’re used to at home, but a few have actually earned nods of approval from these picky eaters.

Whether it’s the crust, the sauce, or just the vibe, these spots have managed to win over folks who grew up eating the real deal in Naples or Rome.

Here are ten chains that surprised Italian expats in the best way possible.

Disclaimer:

All descriptions in this article are for general informational and entertainment purposes only. Experiences, opinions, and product details may vary by location and over time.

Readers should check current menus, availability, and nutrition information directly with each restaurant or brand.

1. Domino’s

Sure, Domino’s might not scream authentic Italian, but some expats have found themselves surprisingly satisfied.

However, it’s not about tradition here – it’s about consistency and convenience when cravings hit late at night.

Certain international locations have adapted their menus to include fresher ingredients and thinner crusts that nod to Neapolitan style.

Though purists may not consider it traditional, plenty of Italians abroad admit they’ve ordered from Domino’s more than once.

Sometimes you just need pizza, and fast delivery wins.

2. Pizza Hut

Growing up in Italy means knowing pizza should never involve stuffed crusts or excessive cheese.

Yet Pizza Hut has surprisingly charmed a handful of expats, especially in countries where options are limited.

Some locations have introduced wood-fired ovens and artisan-style pizzas that actually respect Italian techniques.

If you squint hard enough and order the right thing, it can almost feel like a decent pizzeria back home.

Just saying, don’t judge until you’ve tried their thin crust in Rome!

3. Little Caesars

At first glance, Little Caesars seems like the last place an Italian would praise.

But hear this: when you’re homesick and broke, that Hot-N-Ready box can feel comforting when homesickness strikes

Some expats appreciate the no-frills approach and the fact that it keeps its approach simple and straightforward.

Where other chains oversell their authenticity, Little Caesars just delivers cheap, quick pizza without the drama.

Though it won’t replace cherished family recipes, it scratches the itch when nothing else is open.

4. Papa John’s

Papa John’s slogan about better ingredients and better pizza tends to raise eyebrows among Italians.

Even so, plenty of expats admit they’ve been pleasantly surprised by the quality of the tomato sauce and the freshness of the veggie toppings.

Some international locations even incorporate imported Italian cheeses and olive oil, creating an experience that feels unexpectedly close to home.

Choose toppings carefully and avoid the garlic butter, and the result can be surprisingly respectable.

More than a few Italians confess they’ve become repeat customers despite walking in with serious skepticism.

5. Marco’s Pizza

Founded by an Italian immigrant, Marco’s Pizza carries a bit of heritage in every slice.

Though it’s an American chain now, the recipes still lean toward Old World flavors and techniques.

Expats have praised the Roma crust option, which mimics the thin, crispy base they remember from childhood.

How cool is it that someone actually tried to keep tradition alive in a fast-casual format?

Many Italians overseas consider Marco’s their go-to when they need something familiar without flying home.

6. MOD Pizza

MOD Pizza brings the build-your-own concept to life, giving customers full control over every topping.

Italians who grew up selecting fresh ingredients at local pizzerias often find the experience refreshingly interactive.

Unlike chains that rely on processed meats or lower-quality cheeses, MOD includes quality options like prosciutto and arugula.

Expats appreciate the chance to recreate beloved regional pies without being limited to preset combinations.

No one would mistake it for Napoli, yet the result comes close enough to feel like a small taste of freedom.

7. Blaze Pizza

Blaze Pizza cooks pies in blazing-hot ovens that reach temperatures similar to traditional wood-fired ones.

If you know anything about pizza, you know heat is everything when it comes to getting that perfect char.

Italian expats have noted the blistered crust and smoky flavor that remind them of pizzerias back home.

However, the speed – pizzas ready in under three minutes – still feels almost too American to believe.

Still, when quality meets convenience, even the skeptics can’t help but return.

8. California Pizza Kitchen

California Pizza Kitchen isn’t shy about taking wild liberties with toppings, tossing creations like barbecue chicken onto dough.

Italian expats, surprisingly, sometimes appreciate the creativity and the fact that CPK never pretends to be traditional.

The menu may wander far from classic recipes, but crust quality and fresh ingredients still manage to earn real respect.

Honest branding makes room for forgiveness, and many Italians enjoy fusion when it’s approached with care and solid flavor.

Avoid labeling it Italian pizza, and everyone ends up perfectly happy at the table.

9. Sbarro

Walk into any American mall, and you’ll probably spot Sbarro serving oversized New York-style slices displayed at the counter.

Though it’s far from gourmet, some Italian expats have a soft spot for its New York-style pizza.

If you grew up in southern Italy, the thick, foldable slices might feel oddly nostalgic in their own way.

However, it’s more about the memories and the convenience than any real culinary magic.

Sometimes pizza doesn’t need to be perfect, it just needs to be there.

10. Round Table Pizza

Round Table Pizza started in California and built a loyal following with its King Arthur theme.

Though the branding feels more medieval than Mediterranean, the pizza itself has earned some Italian praise.

Certain expats enjoy the generous toppings and the slightly thicker crust that still maintains a good chew.

Where other chains go too heavy or too bland, Round Table strikes a balance that feels satisfying.

If you’re on the West Coast and missing home, this spot might just surprise you.