8 Wildly Unique Milkshakes You Have To Try At Least Once
Ever sipped something so strange, so surprisingly delicious, that you had to do a double-take? Milkshakes have evolved well beyond vanilla and chocolate.
Pickles, matcha, and other unexpected ingredients blend into flavors you never thought could work together. Discover some of the wildest, most unforgettable milkshakes that will make your taste buds do a happy dance.
1. The Muppets Pickle Milkshake
Walt Disney World knows how to surprise guests, and this bright green creation does exactly that. Vanilla ice cream meets dill pickle brine in a combo that sounds weird but tastes amazing.
Tangy and creamy collide in every sip, topped with whipped cream, chocolate sprinkles, and a whole pickle spear for good measure.
Pickle lovers will feel like they’ve found their soulmate in shake form. Sweet meets salty in a way that makes total sense once you try it.
If you’re brave enough to embrace the unexpected, this one’s calling your name.
2. Black Licorice Milkshake
Black licorice divides people faster than pineapple on pizza. On Any Sundae took the bold step of turning this polarizing candy into a creamy shake.
Vanilla ice cream blends with licorice’s herbal, slightly sweet flavor for a taste that’s unforgettable.
If you’re part of Team Licorice, this shake is your dream come true. The flavor is strong, unapologetic, and seriously nostalgic.
Just saying, haters might want to sit this one out while fans celebrate every slurp.
3. Guava Milkshake
Bocas House brings Miami vibes straight to your straw with this tropical treasure. Fresh guava transforms into a sweet, tangy shake that tastes like sunshine in a cup.
Each sip feels like a mini vacation, transporting you to palm trees and ocean breezes.
Guava’s unique flavor profile makes this shake stand out from the crowd. It’s fruity without being too sugary, refreshing without losing that creamy texture.
Perfect for anyone craving something exotic and delicious at the same time.
4. Cinnamon Bun Shake
Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer created a monster of a milkshake that’s basically breakfast and dessert in one glass. Vanilla ice cream gets swirled with cinnamon, then crowned with an entire cinnamon roll.
Cream cheese icing drips down the sides while crushed Cinnamon Toast Crunch adds extra crunch.
This isn’t just a shake, it’s a full-blown experience that requires a fork and serious appetite. Instagram-worthy doesn’t even begin to describe it.
Share this beast with friends or tackle it solo if you’re feeling heroic.
5. Matcha Milkshake
Mooyah took the trendy green tea powder everyone’s obsessed with and turned it into shake form. Vanilla ice cream blends with matcha’s earthy, slightly grassy flavor for something refreshingly different.
Topped with whipped cream and a dusting of matcha powder, it looks as good as it tastes.
Matcha fans will appreciate the authentic flavor that’s not too sweet. It’s energizing yet calming, like a zen garden you can drink.
Plus, you get to feel fancy while sipping something that’s actually pretty good for you.
6. Avocado Milkshake
Avocado toast stepped aside to let this creamy green shake shine. Popular in Southeast Asia and Latin America, avocado shakes blend the fruit’s buttery texture with sweetened condensed milk.
The result is ridiculously smooth, subtly sweet, and surprisingly refreshing.
Skeptics become believers after one sip of this velvety concoction. Avocado’s mild flavor works perfectly in dessert form without tasting like guacamole.
It’s healthier than most shakes too, which means you can feel slightly less guilty about dessert for dinner.
7. Rose Water Milkshake
Rose water has been flavoring Middle Eastern and Indian desserts for centuries, and now it’s conquering milkshakes. This delicate floral shake tastes like drinking a bouquet in the best possible way.
Paired with vanilla or strawberry ice cream, it’s romantic and refreshing at once.
A little rose water goes a long way, creating perfumed sweetness without tasting like soap. The flavor is subtle, elegant, and perfect for anyone wanting to try something beautifully different.
Share your thoughts below if you’re team floral or team traditional flavors
8. Peanut Butter Bacon Milkshake
Elvis Presley loved peanut butter and bacon sandwiches, so naturally someone turned that combo into a milkshake. Creamy peanut butter ice cream gets studded with crispy bacon bits for a sweet and salty explosion.
It sounds absolutely wild, but the flavors work together like a delicious conspiracy.
Bacon in dessert isn’t new, but it still surprises people every time. The salty crunch cuts through the rich peanut butter perfectly, creating balance and intrigue.
Pass this on to someone who’d smile reading about food that breaks all the rules deliciously.
