6 ’70s Sitcom Stars Who Almost Got Their Own Show
The 1970s were a golden era for television comedy, a time when laugh tracks ruled and Hollywood dreams were made overnight. Countless stars were launched into superstardom, but not every talented actor got the chance to lead their own series.
Some came tantalizingly close, starring in pilots that never took off or landing roles that were snatched away at the last minute. Behind the bright studio lights and Hollywood glamour, these six performers almost became household names, their charm and talent ready to light up screens nationwide.
Dive in and discover the near-misses that could have changed TV history forever; you won’t believe who almost had their own show!
1. Mickey Rooney – Nearly Oscar Madison
Before Jack Klugman became the lovably grumpy sportswriter Oscar Madison, Mickey Rooney was seriously considered for the role in The Odd Couple TV adaptation. Imagine that!
Rooney, already a Hollywood legend with decades of film experience, could have brought a completely different energy to the messy apartment and witty banter.
Though producers ultimately went with Klugman, Rooney’s consideration shows how networks were thinking outside the box. His explosive personality and comedic timing would have created a wildly different dynamic opposite Tony Randall’s Felix.
Sometimes the road not taken is just as fascinating as the one that was.
2. Martin Balsam – The Other Oscar Contender
Here’s a plot twist: Martin Balsam, the Oscar-winning character actor, also competed for the Oscar Madison role. Known for playing serious, thoughtful characters in films, Balsam auditioning for a sitcom lead shows how television was attracting serious talent during the ’70s boom.
His refined acting style would have given The Odd Couple a completely different flavor. Picture a more sophisticated, less slobby Oscar trading barbs with Felix.
Networks loved testing different chemistry combinations before committing to a series. Balsam eventually found TV success elsewhere, but this near-miss remains an intriguing what-if scenario.
3. Dean Martin – Almost Felix Unger
Wait, Dean Martin as the neat-freak Felix Unger? That’s right!
The smooth crooner and Rat Pack member was actually considered for the fussy, perfectionist roommate role. Talk about casting against type!
Martin’s cool, laid-back persona seemed the opposite of Felix’s neurotic tendencies, but producers saw potential in the contrast.
Eventually, Tony Randall’s pitch-perfect portrayal became television history. However, Martin’s involvement in discussions shows how networks explored unexpected casting choices.
His star power could have launched the show differently, though imagining Dino obsessing over cleaning schedules is pretty hilarious, just saying.
4. Art Carney – The Felix That Never Was
Fresh off his legendary run as Ed Norton on The Honeymooners, Art Carney was another contender for Felix Unger. His impeccable comedic timing and ability to play lovable oddballs made him a natural consideration.
Networks knew Carney could deliver both physical comedy and emotional depth.
Though he didn’t land The Odd Couple, Carney’s career flourished with other projects, including an Oscar win for Harry and Tonto. His consideration proves that casting directors were hunting for established comedy veterans.
Sometimes losing one role opens doors to even better opportunities, and Carney’s career trajectory definitely supports that theory.
5. Tim Conway – Charter Dreams Grounded
After making audiences laugh on McHale’s Navy, Tim Conway finally got his own sitcom in 1970. The Tim Conway Show centered on a bumbling charter airline operator, perfect for his slapstick genius and impeccable slow-burn delivery.
Fans were excited to see him headline a series tailored to his unique talents.
Sadly, the show crash-landed after just 13 episodes due to low ratings. Sometimes even talented performers can’t overcome weak time slots or tough competition.
Conway bounced back spectacularly, becoming a beloved fixture on The Carol Burnett Show and winning multiple Emmys.
6. Demond Wilson – Baby, It Didn’t Last
After years of success alongside Redd Foxx on Sanford and Son, Demond Wilson earned his own starring vehicle in 1978. Baby…
I’m Back! featured Wilson as a husband returning to his family after disappearing for seven years. The premise had potential for both comedy and heartfelt moments, showcasing Wilson’s range beyond straight-man reactions.
Unfortunately, the show vanished almost as quickly as Wilson’s character had, canceled after one season. Audiences couldn’t quite connect with the concept despite Wilson’s charm.
Launching a successful spinoff or follow-up series proved challenging for many ’70s sitcom stars.
