Would You Dare To Dine At Stella’s, Kentucky’s Most Haunted Restaurant
If a plate could whisper, Stella’s on Broadway in downtown Paducah, Kentucky, might have the eeriest dinner conversation in town.
Food and folklore sit side by side here, pouring out small town charm with a shiver of goosebumps, like a little river town that enjoys its secrets as much as its suppers.
Ready to pull up a chair and see why people rave about the service, the taste, and that tiny chill that sneaks up your spine?
Disclaimer
The information provided in this article reflects general impressions, guest experiences, and publicly available details about Stella’s on Broadway at the time of writing.
Hours, menu items, pricing, and availability may change, and individual experiences may vary.
1. A First Glimpse On Broadway
Step onto Broadway and the brick storefront of Stella’s feels like a friendly handshake.
Historic Paducah charm blends with modern polish as the entrance glows for hungry wanderers.
The creak of the door even sounds like the beginning of a mystery.
Inside, cozy tables and a warm buzz create a welcoming space with just a hint of intrigue.
2. The Haunted Whispers
Locals share lighthearted stories about a playful presence that lingers in quiet corners.
Nothing becomes frightening, and the tales bring a gentle campfire sparkle to the night.
It feels more like a Scooby Doo-style shiver than a scare, complete with knowing grins.
Servers mention tiny flickers or drafts, and guests treat it like part of the fun.
3. Service With Heart
Reviews constantly praise the staff for warmth, attention, and skill.
Servers offer confident guidance that makes choosing dishes feel effortless.
Names like Enetria, LaReisha, and Jenitha appear again and again thanks to memorable service.
Guests leave feeling cared for in a way that outlasts any playful rumor.
4. Plates That Pop
Plates arrive with bold color, height, and texture from start to finish.
Flavors stay confident without overwhelming the palate.
Tuna appetizers and fried cheese often end up as fan favorites worth photographing.
Rotating specials keep the menu fresh, with crisp edges and intentional seasoning throughout.
5. Tuna Starter Spotlight
This starter earns its reputation through pristine cuts and bright citrus perfume.
A gentle crunch adds contrast and resets expectations in one bite.
Servers recommend it often because it consistently delights newcomers.
Balance leads the way here, allowing freshness to shine without fuss.
6. Fish And Chips Favorite
The fish arrives crackly outside and tender inside, creating a little magic on the plate.
Where many versions feel heavy, this one stays light and bright with every bite.
A squeeze of lemon wakes up the whole dish with a cheerful citrus burst.
Portions run generous and the crisp texture lasts right down to the final forkful.
7. Cotton Candy Curtain Call
Sometimes dessert appears as a fluffy swirl of cotton candy that surprises the table.
Nostalgia mixes with fun presentation to create a playful finale.
Guests describe it like a family-friendly magic trick that brings instant smiles.
Quieter desserts are available too, but every ending carries warmth and charm.
8. Lunch Hour Wins
Lunch at Stella’s moves with smooth pacing that never feels rushed.
Plates land fresh, crisp, and perfectly sized for a midday break.
Regulars rely on it for both lunch and dinner thanks to steady quality.
Planning ahead can help during busy windows, though walk-ins often find luck.
9. Atmosphere And Layout
The dining room blends soft historic textures with modern comfort and gentle warmth.
Lighting adds a mellow glow that makes each table feel important.
Conversation flows easily thanks to layout choices that avoid crowding.
Guests appreciate how the relaxed atmosphere supports long meals that feel surprisingly short.
10. Price Point Sweet Spot
Most dishes fall in the ten-to-twenty-dollar range, offering true value.
Quality routinely exceeds cost, which surprises first-time visitors.
Budget-friendly pricing makes treating yourself feel easy and comfortable.
Specials shift day to day, and careful plating enhances the experience.
11. Hours And Best Times
Hours run Tuesday through Wednesday from 11 AM to 9 PM.
Thursday through Saturday hold the same hours, with Saturday beginning at 10 AM.
Sunday and Monday stay fully closed, so planning matters.
Early dinners or late lunches offer the calmest pace, while peak times bring lively energy.
12. How To Find It
You’ll find Stella’s at 202 Broadway St in downtown Paducah.
Coordinates 37.0874605, -88.5957409 take you directly to the door.
Street parking and downtown lots nearby usually make things simple.
Arriving a bit early adds ease and lets you enjoy a charming stroll around the block.
13. Reservations And Contact
For details, the fastest check is the website at https://www.stellaspaducah.com/.
Those who prefer a call can reach the team at +1 270-534-5123.
Staff can share wait times, accessibility notes, and menu tips.
Weekend reservations help, but same-day visits often work before the dinner rush.
14. Final Nudge To Visit
Dinner here comes with flavor, friendliness, and a gentle hint of mystery.
Comfort and curiosity settle easily into the same booth.
You’ll leave full, happy, and ready to share a small story of your own.
Bring a friend, check the hours, and keep room for dessert because endings matter.
